So, for sure:
If you setup the D-Link as open, the wireless workstation will associate the D-Link and gets IP from the DHCP server that is running on the D-Link.
When you setup the for example WPA security only and restarts the D-Link, computer will associate with it, but dont get the IP...
(When you can't get IP on WPA/TKIP security mode, it typically means that you have bad security key)
Ensure that you are connecting thru the standart windows interface - accessible thru the flashing icon with one computer...
You should also try to delete wireless profile in zero configuration between the change of security mode.