As displayed in the ipconfig-screenshot you have not added the domain nashfinch.com in the DNS-suffix order, but in the question you say you have done that. So where have you added the DNS-suffix for nashfinch.com?
Is the last nslookup-screenshot from the same host as the ipconfig-screenshot?
The forwarders-screenshot looks a little bit confusing when you're forwarding all unresolved queries to both internal and external server addresses. It would be better to configure conditional forwarding so the unresolved queries for the given domain is forwarded to a server responsible for the domain.